American Family.
Priced in 9 cities we track, for the 25-55 driver, Full coverage, Good credit bracket.
1
Times cheapest
#5.9
Average rank
0.34
NAIC complaint index, Well below average
What the complaint index means
The NAIC complaint index compares how many complaints an insurer gets to how big it is. 1.00 is the industry baseline. American Family sits at 0.34, meaning it gets noticeably fewer complaints than expected for its size. 2026 data, SaveMaxAuto NAIC complaint index summary.
#CityRank thereMonthly
01
Fargo, NDFiled rate
#4 of 14
$66.00
02
Provo, UTFiled rate
#5 of 8
$136.00
03
Phoenix, AZFiled rate
#1 of 9
$144.67
04
Saint Paul, MNFiled rate
#5 of 8
$158.00
05
Warwick, RIFiled rate
#7 of 9
$254.67
06
St. Louis, MOFiled rate
#8 of 10
$295.92
07
Salt Lake City, UTFiled rate
#8 of 9
$303.00
08
Denver, COFiled rate
#7 of 8
$316.25
09
Providence, RIFiled rate
#8 of 10
$355.33