Progressive.
Priced in 88 cities we track, for the 25-55 driver, Full coverage, Good credit bracket.
6
Times cheapest
#4.1
Average rank
0.93
NAIC complaint index, Near average
What the complaint index means
The NAIC complaint index compares how many complaints an insurer gets to how big it is. 1.00 is the industry baseline. Progressive sits at 0.93, meaning it gets roughly the complaints you'd expect for its size. 2026 data, NAIC-based comparison via Zeember.
#CityRank thereMonthly
01
Santa Fe, NMFiled rate
#1 of 8
$97.00
02
Buffalo, NYFiled rate
#1 of 8
$103.08
03
Fort Wayne, INFiled rate
#3 of 9
$115.75
04
Raleigh, NCFiled rate
#1 of 7
$116.00
05
Lexington, KYFiled rate
#1 of 10
$117.00
06
Aurora, ILFiled rate
#3 of 9
$123.00
07
San Diego, CAFiled rate
#1 of 4
$123.58
08
Honolulu, HIFiled rate
#6 of 7
$123.67
09
Naperville, ILFiled rate
#5 of 10
$124.00
10
Portland, MEFiled rate
#3 of 8
$125.08
11
Burlington, VTState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$128.00
12
Montpelier, VTState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$128.00
13
Bangor, MEState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$129.00
14
Sioux Falls, SDFiled rate
#2 of 9
$130.25
15
Casper, WYState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$131.00
16
Huntington, WVFiled rate
#3 of 5
$132.00
17
Charlotte, NCFiled rate
#1 of 7
$135.00
18
Indianapolis, INFiled rate
#4 of 9
$140.00
19
Cleveland, OHState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$148.00
20
Columbus, OHState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$148.00
21
Provo, UTFiled rate
#7 of 8
$148.00
22
Cedar Rapids, IAFiled rate
#2 of 8
$149.08
23
Hilo, HIState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$151.00
24
Jackson, MSFiled rate
#7 of 9
$153.00
25
Nashua, NHFiled rate
#7 of 10
$153.75
26
Boston, MAFiled rate
#4 of 9
$154.00
27
Seattle, WAFiled rate
#4 of 9
$155.08
28
Overland Park, KSFiled rate
#4 of 9
$158.83
29
Fairbanks, AKFiled rate
#2 of 6
$163.67
30
Savannah, GAFiled rate
#2 of 6
$164.25
31
Chicago, ILFiled rate
#3 of 3
$169.50
32
Manchester, NHFiled rate
#7 of 10
$169.50
33
Nashville, TNFiled rate
#9 of 9
$175.58
34
Des Moines, IAFiled rate
#7 of 11
$175.67
35
Charleston, WVState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$179.00
36
Bismarck, NDState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$180.00
37
Richmond, VAFiled rate
#6 of 10
$184.00
38
Tulsa, OKFiled rate
#2 of 10
$184.00
39
Virginia Beach, VAFiled rate
#6 of 8
$186.00
40
Los Angeles, CAFiled rate
#2 of 4
$187.40
41
Oklahoma City, OKFiled rate
#3 of 10
$190.00
42
Lincoln, NEFiled rate
#6 of 8
$193.17
43
Salt Lake City, UTFiled rate
#5 of 9
$193.42
44
Missoula, MTFiled rate
#6 of 8
$195.92
45
Spokane, WAFiled rate
#3 of 7
$196.50
46
Eugene, ORState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$199.00
47
Warwick, RIFiled rate
#2 of 9
$203.17
48
Montgomery, ALFiled rate
#8 of 9
$208.25
49
Dover, DEFiled rate
#4 of 12
$210.00
50
Annapolis, MDState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$211.00
51
Omaha, NEFiled rate
#6 of 8
$215.08
52
Charleston, WVFiled rate
#6 of 8
$217.58
53
Columbia, SCFiled rate
#5 of 7
$219.75
54
Denver, COFiled rate
#3 of 8
$220.92
55
Rapid City, SDFiled rate
#4 of 9
$221.92
56
Charleston, SCFiled rate
#5 of 7
$224.08
57
Wichita, KSState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$225.00
58
Grand Rapids, MIFiled rate
#5 of 9
$225.08
59
Birmingham, ALFiled rate
#8 of 10
$229.83
60
Billings, MTFiled rate
#5 of 7
$231.42
61
New York City, NYFiled rate
#2 of 6
$231.90
62
Gulfport, MSFiled rate
#5 of 7
$233.33
63
Houston, TXFiled rate
#5 of 10
$239.33
64
Pittsburgh, PAFiled rate
#8 of 8
$239.92
65
Wilmington, DEFiled rate
#5 of 9
$243.50
66
Austin, TXState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$247.00
67
Worcester, MAFiled rate
#4 of 8
$247.42
68
Providence, RIFiled rate
#4 of 10
$251.25
69
Baltimore, MDFiled rate
#5 of 7
$259.00
70
Atlanta, GAFiled rate
#4 of 5
$260.83
71
Colorado Springs, COFiled rate
#4 of 9
$261.75
72
Phoenix, AZFiled rate
#7 of 9
$265.67
73
Tucson, AZFiled rate
#4 of 5
$266.67
74
Albuquerque, NMFiled rate
#5 of 9
$270.00
75
Reno, NVFiled rate
#3 of 7
$274.42
76
Fayetteville, ARFiled rate
#7 of 9
$278.75
77
St. Louis, MOFiled rate
#7 of 10
$291.17
78
Jersey City, NJFiled rate
#5 of 8
$303.75
79
Orlando, FLState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$311.00
80
Louisville, KYFiled rate
#8 of 9
$312.17
81
Hartford, CTFiled rate
#5 of 9
$314.83
82
Bridgeport, CTFiled rate
#5 of 9
$319.58
83
Baton Rouge, LAState-average estimate
#2 of 3
$327.00
84
Washington, DCFiled rate
#4 of 6
$362.00
85
Portland, ORFiled rate
#9 of 9
$383.25
86
Newark, NJFiled rate
#5 of 7
$383.92
87
Detroit, MIFiled rate
#3 of 6
$437.00
88
New Orleans, LAFiled rate
#6 of 7
$597.67